logo-lakshmshree
Posted on  October 16, 2024 under  by Ayush Maurya

Difference Between Equity and Preference Shares: Better?

If you’ve ever considered investing in the stock market, you’ve probably heard terms like “equity shares” and “preference shares” tossed around. But what's the difference between equity and preference shares, and why does it matter? These shares aren’t just financial jargon—they’re two distinct ways to own a piece of a company, each with its own perks and pitfalls.

In this guide, we’ll break down the difference between equity and preference shares so you can make smarter investment choices. Whether you’re looking for higher returns or a more stable income, understanding these options can help you find the right fit for your financial goals.

What Are Equity Shares?

Equity shares, also known as ordinary shares, signify partial ownership in a company. When you hold equity shares, you are entitled to a portion of the company's profits, which are distributed as dividends, though these are not guaranteed and fluctuate with the company’s performance. Equity shareholders are often regarded as the true owners of the company since they bear both the risks and rewards of the business.

One key aspect of equity shares is giving shareholders voting rights, allowing them to influence critical decisions, such as electing board members or approving major company policies. Additionally, equity shareholders stand to benefit from capital appreciation if the company’s stock value increases over time, providing potential for significant long-term gains. However, in the event of liquidation, equity shareholders are last in line to receive any remaining assets after all debts and other liabilities are settled.

Features of Equity Shares

  • Ownership and Voting Rights: Equity shareholders are part-owners of the company and usually have voting rights on significant matters like electing the board of directors.
  • Variable Dividends: Dividends on equity shares aren’t fixed. They depend on the company’s profits, so you could earn a lot—or nothing at all.
  • Potential for Capital Gains: The value of equity shares can increase if the company performs well, offering the chance for capital gains.
  • Last Claim on Assets: In case the company is liquidated, equity shareholders are paid last, after all debts and preference shares are settled.

Advantages & Disadvantages of Equity Shares

Advantages & Disadvantages of Equity Shares

Types of Equity Shares

  • Ordinary Equity Shares: These are the most common type and come with voting rights, potential dividends, and higher risks.
  • Bonus Shares: These are extra shares issued to existing shareholders, typically at no extra cost, based on the number of shares already owned.
  • Rights Shares: These are offered to existing shareholders at a discounted price, allowing them to buy more shares before they’re offered to the public.
  • Sweat Equity Shares: Issued to employees or directors, these shares are rewarded for their hard work and dedication to the company.

About DVR (Differential Voting Rights) Shares

DVR shares, or Differential Voting Rights shares, are a unique type of equity share that provides varied voting rights compared to ordinary equity shares. In most cases, DVR shares offer fewer voting rights per share but compensate investors with higher dividends. These shares appeal to investors more interested in income than control, as they offer enhanced returns without the burden of frequent decision-making power.

However, DVR shares are relatively rare in the Indian stock market, with only a handful of companies currently offering them. DVR shares can be a good choice for investors seeking higher income but with less interest in voting on company matters.

What Are Preference Shares?

Preference shares, sometimes referred to as preferred stock, represent a different class of ownership in a company. Unlike equity shares, preference shares come with a fixed dividend that is paid out before any dividends to equity shareholders, providing a more predictable income stream. Preference shareholders have priority over equity shareholders in the payment of dividends and also in the event of liquidation, where they are repaid before equity holders, though after all debts are cleared.

However, preference shares generally do not have voting rights, meaning preference shareholders typically have little say in the company's day-to-day management or strategic decisions.

Features of Preference Shares

  • Fixed Dividends: Preference shareholders receive dividends at a fixed rate, providing a predictable income stream.
  • Priority Over Equity Shares: Preference shareholders are paid before equity shareholders in terms of both dividends and liquidation proceeds.
  • Limited or No Voting Rights: Most preference shares do not include voting rights, limiting shareholder influence over company decisions.
  • Variety of Types: Preference shares come in various forms, each with unique characteristics to suit different investment needs.

Advantages & Disadvantages of Preference Shares

Advantages & Disadvantages of Preference Shares

Types of Preference Shares

  • Cumulative Preference Shares: Dividends accumulate if they are not paid out in a given year, ensuring that shareholders receive back payments in future profitable years.
  • Non-Cumulative Preference Shares: Missed dividend payments are not carried forward, meaning shareholders lose out on unpaid dividends from unprofitable years.
  • Convertible Preference Shares: These shares can be converted into a predetermined number of equity shares, offering the potential for capital appreciation.
  • Redeemable Preference Shares: Issued with a redemption date, the company buys these shares back after a certain period, usually at a set price.
  • Non-Redeemable Preference Shares: Unlike redeemable shares, these shares are not subject to buyback by the company, allowing investors to hold them indefinitely.
  • Participating Preference Shares: In addition to fixed dividends, shareholders can participate in additional profits after equity shareholders receive their dividends.
  • Non-Participating Preference Shares: These shares are limited to fixed dividends only and do not entitle shareholders to any extra profit distribution beyond that.

Key Differences Between Equity and Preference Shares

Equity shares represent ownership in a company and provide voting rights, allowing shareholders to influence company decisions. However, they carry higher risks, as dividends fluctuate with profits. Preference shares, on the other hand, offer fixed dividends and give priority over equity shares when it comes to payouts and claims on assets. Though they usually lack voting rights, preference shares are favoured by investors seeking steady income and lower risk.

Now, let’s break down the specific differences between equity shares and preference shares in more detail:

ParameterEquity SharesPreference Shares
DefinitionOwnership share with voting rightsShare with preferential dividend and asset claim rights
Dividend PayoutVariable, depends on company profitsFixed, regular payout regardless of profit levels
Dividend RateFluctuates according to earningsFixed rate, often predetermined
Voting RightsYes, shareholders can vote in company mattersTypically no voting rights
Priority in PayoutPaid after preference shares in liquidationPaid before equity shares
Growth PotentialHigh potential, tied to company performanceLimited to fixed dividends
Risk LevelHigher due to market volatilityLower, with guaranteed dividend payouts
Bonus SharesEligible to receive bonus sharesGenerally not eligible for bonus shares
ConvertibilityNon-convertibleCan be either convertible or non-convertible
RedemptionNon-redeemable, held indefinitelyCan be redeemable or non-redeemable
Capital RepaymentLast in line during company liquidationRepaid before equity shares
Arrears of DividendNo entitlement to unpaid dividendsCumulative shares may receive unpaid dividends in future years
Start Investing - LISPL Investment

Understanding Debentures Alongside Equity and Preference Shares

When comparing equity shares, preference shares, and debentures, it’s essential to understand how each serves a unique purpose in financing and investment. Debentures are a form of debt rather than equity, meaning they don’t represent ownership in a company. Instead, debenture holders are creditors who lend money to a company in exchange for a fixed interest rate over a set period. Unlike equity and preference shares, debentures don’t provide dividends or voting rights but offer lower risk and priority in repayment.

ParameterEquity SharesPreference SharesDebentures
NatureRepresents ownershipRepresents partial ownership with fixed dividendsRepresents debt; company borrows funds from investors
ReturnDividends and capital appreciationFixed dividendsFixed interest payments
Voting RightsYesTypically noNo
Risk LevelHigher, due to market volatilityLower than equity, higher than debenturesLowest risk among the three
Repayment PriorityLast in liquidationBefore equity sharesPriority over both equity and preference shares
Investment TypeGrowth-orientedIncome-orientedIncome-oriented, low risk
SecurityUnsecuredUnsecured, unless specified otherwiseCan be secured or unsecured, often backed by assets

Debentures offer an alternative to equity and preference shares, allowing investors to choose based on their financial goals and risk tolerance.

Equity vs. Preference Shares: Which One is Right for You?

Choosing between equity shares and preference shares depends on your investment strategy, risk tolerance, and income needs. Equity shares are ideal for those who want to participate in a company’s growth and decision-making actively. They offer higher potential returns through capital gains and dividends but come with greater risks, as they’re affected by market fluctuations.

Preference shares, however, are better suited for investors prioritising steady income over growth. With fixed dividends and priority over equity shares in asset claims, preference shares are less volatile, making them appealing to risk-averse investors.

Real-Life Examples of Equity and Preference Shares: What to Prefer?

When choosing between equity shares and preference shares, consider how each aligns with your financial goals:

  • For Growth-Focused Investors: Equity shares offer the potential for higher returns and capital gains, especially if the company grows. This makes them ideal for those looking for long-term appreciation and comfortable with market volatility. For example, if you're investing in a rapidly growing tech company, equity shares could yield significant returns over time.
  • For Income-Oriented Investors: Preference shares are better suited for those prioritising steady income with lower risk. Since preference shareholders receive fixed dividends and have priority over equity shareholders in asset claims, this type of investment is more stable. For instance, if you're seeking a reliable stream of dividends from a well-established utility company, preference shares can provide that security.

In summary, equity shares are ideal for investors who want growth and are willing to accept more risk, while preference shares are better for those who seek steady income and prefer lower risk.

Conclusion

The difference between equity and preference shares comes from risk, return, and control. Equity shares provide ownership rights and the potential for high returns, but they carry more risk and are influenced by market changes. Preference shares, on the other hand, offer fixed dividends and priority in asset claims, making them more stable but with limited growth potential. Both types of shares have their own unique advantages, and choosing the right one depends on your financial goals and risk tolerance.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the main difference between equity and preference shares?

The main difference between equity and preference shares is that equity shares represent ownership with voting rights and potential for high returns, while preference shares provide fixed dividends, priority in dividends and asset claims but usually lack voting rights.

2. Are preference shares safer than equity shares?

Yes, preference shares are generally considered safer because they offer fixed dividends and priority in payouts over equity shares, making them less volatile.

3. Can I convert preference shares into equity shares?

In some cases, yes. Certain types of preference shares are convertible, meaning they can be converted into equity shares after a specified period or under certain conditions.

4. Do equity shareholders always receive dividends?

No, equity dividends depend on the company's profits and are not guaranteed. Dividends may vary or even be skipped if the company doesn’t perform well.

5. Who gets paid first in the event of a company's liquidation?

Preference shareholders are paid before equity shareholders in the event of liquidation. However, debenture holders and other creditors are paid even before preference shareholders.

6. Which is better for long-term investment: equity or preference shares?

It depends on your goals. Equity shares offer long-term growth potential, while preference shares provide stable income. For growth, equity is better; for stable returns, preference shares are preferable.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for educational purposes only. Please note that the data related to the mentioned companies may change over time. The securities referenced are provided as examples and should not be considered as recommendations.

Ayush Maurya

Written by Ayush Maurya

Ayush is a seasoned financial markets expert with over 3years of experience. He has a passion for breaking down complex financial concepts into simple, digestible terms. Through his 50+ articles, Ayush has helped countless individuals navigate the often intimidating world of finance.

open-account-ad-2

Social Share

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Loading
CIN No U74110MH2005PLC157942     |    Member Ship Details     |    BSE-3281     |    NSE-12817     |    MCX-55910     |    DP:IN-DP-CDSL-490-2008     |    DPID:12059100    |    SEBI Regn. No.: INZ000170330     |    Mutual Fund: ARN-77739    |    Research Analyst: registration number INH000014395
logo-lakshmshree-white
Lakshmishree Investment & Securities Ltd. was incorporated in 2005. We are a Corporate Member of NSE, BSE, MCX and Depository Participant with CDSL.
Most Popular in LISL
Copyright @ 2024 © Lakshmishree Investment & Securities Ltd. All Right Reserved.